Apple Pie with a Crust cocktail

Apple Pie with a Crust

Collins Glass
Sweet
Fruity
Dessert
Autumn
Easy
Coconut
Apple

A sweet and nostalgic cocktail that mimics the flavor of a freshly baked apple pie. The combination of coconut rum and apple juice creates a surprisingly pastry-like profile, finished with aromatic cinnamon. Ideally served over ice for a refreshing treat, though it can also be warmed for cozy autumn evenings.

What it tastes like

The drink leads with an aroma of sweet apple and synthetic coconut, followed by a sharp hit of dry spice. The palate is thin and sugary, dominated by fruit juice and tropical esters with very little alcohol bite. The finish is short and clean, leaving a lingering warmth from the cinnamon on the tongue.

Flavour profile

Sweet
Strength
Bitter
Complexity

Ingredients

  • Malibu Coconut Rum1.5 oz
  • Apple Juice4.5 oz
  • Ground Cinnamon3 dashes

Preparation

  1. 1

    Fill a Collins glass with fresh ice cubes.

  2. 2

    Pour the Malibu coconut rum and apple juice over the ice.

  3. 3

    Stir gently to combine the ingredients thoroughly.

  4. 4

    Sprinkle the dashes of ground cinnamon over the top as a garnish.

Substitutions

  • Malibu Coconut RumCoconut milk mixed with white rum — This swap increases the alcohol content and provides a much creamier mouthfeel.
  • Apple JuiceUnfiltered apple cider — Using cider introduces a tart acidity and a thicker, cloudier appearance.
  • Ground CinnamonGrated nutmeg — Nutmeg offers a woodier, more savory spice profile compared to the direct sweetness of cinnamon.

Variations

Hot Apple Crust

Heat the apple juice on a stovetop before combining with the rum for a warm seasonal variation.

Bourbon Crust

Replace half of the coconut rum with bourbon to add oak and vanilla notes that mimic a baked pastry.

Don't have every bottle? Let Mixolog build one from your bar →
Mixolog Logo
Mixolog

Bringing the craft of the bar home — AI-powered recipes and a curated library of classics.

Quick Links

© 2026 Mixolog Inc. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service